Planned giving might sound traditional, but your strategy for finding donors can be completely modern. Your social media followers are more than just numbers; they are a community of people who have raised their hands to say they care about your work. The challenge is turning that passive support into a long-term commitment. This is where a modern legacy giving program comes in. By using tools like direct messaging to build real, one-to-one relationships, you can identify and nurture your most passionate followers. This guide will show you how to bridge the gap between your social media engagement and sustainable, long-term funding.

Key Takeaways

• Start simple and focus on loyalty: You don't need a complex program to begin. Concentrate on accepting straightforward gifts like bequests and identifying your most consistent, long-term donors as your first prospects.
• Make it about connection, not just a transaction: A planned gift is the ultimate expression of a donor's trust. Nurture genuine, one-to-one relationships with your supporters, as these connections are the true foundation for securing future gifts.
• Integrate legacy giving into your current work: You don't need a separate, large-scale marketing campaign. Simply add legacy giving messages into your existing communications, like your website, email newsletters, and social media posts, to make it a familiar option for supporters.

What Is a Legacy Giving Program?

A legacy giving program is your nonprofit's organized effort to secure future gifts from supporters. Also known as planned giving, it’s a way for donors to arrange a future donation of money or assets. Think of it as a supporter making a promise today to leave a lasting impact on your mission tomorrow. These aren't your typical cash donations. Instead, they come through arrangements like a will, a retirement account, or a life insurance policy where your nonprofit is named as a beneficiary.

For donors, this is a powerful way to support a cause they're passionate about, often allowing them to make a much larger gift than they could during their lifetime. It’s a chance to cement their values and create a legacy that outlives them. Plus, these planned gifts can offer significant tax benefits to the donor's estate, making it a thoughtful part of their financial planning. By creating a formal program, you make it easier for supporters to take this step and give them a clear path to follow. A guide to legacy giving can provide a foundational understanding for your team as you get started.

How is legacy giving different?

Legacy giving stands apart from your annual fund drives or one-time donation campaigns because it’s all about the future. While an immediate donation helps you meet today's needs, a legacy gift is designed to sustain your mission for years to come. It’s a long-term partnership with a donor. The focus is on a gift that will be realized later, often after the donor has passed away. This structure allows supporters to plan a significant contribution without touching their current finances or assets. It’s their way of ensuring the work they believe in continues, making their personal values a permanent part of your organization's story.

The role of planned giving in your strategy

Integrating planned giving into your fundraising strategy is about more than just securing future income; it’s about deepening relationships. When you talk to supporters about legacy gifts, you’re inviting them into a conversation about their values, their life, and what they want their impact on the world to be. This isn't a simple transaction. It's a connection that can lead to a supporter feeling more invested in your mission right now. In fact, donors who include a nonprofit in their estate plans often become more generous with their annual giving, too. Building these one-to-one relationships is the foundation of a strong planned giving program and a more sustainable future for your organization.

Common myths about legacy giving

Let’s clear up a few common myths about legacy giving, starting with the biggest one: that it’s only for the ultra-wealthy. The truth is, anyone can leave a legacy gift. You don't need a sprawling estate or a massive bank account to make a meaningful difference. Many planned gifts are surprisingly modest, like a small percentage of a retirement account or a few thousand dollars from an estate. A donor could choose to leave just 1% of their assets, which can provide incredible support for your work without taking away from their family. The key is to show supporters that legacy giving is accessible to everyone who cares about your cause, regardless of their income.

Types of Legacy Gifts You Can Accept

When you hear "legacy giving," you might immediately think of a large sum of money left in a will. While that’s one popular way to give, it’s far from the only option. Legacy giving includes a variety of planned gifts, both simple and complex, that supporters can use to make a lasting impact. Understanding these different types is the first step to building a program that meets donors where they are.

Your role isn't to be a financial advisor, but to be a helpful partner. By learning the basics, you can have more confident conversations and guide supporters toward the resources they need. Let’s walk through the most common types of legacy gifts you can start accepting. This will help you decide what to include in your program and how to talk about these powerful giving methods with your community. The one-to-one relationships you build with supporters are the perfect foundation for these deeper conversations about their long-term impact.

Bequests

A bequest is a gift made through a person’s will or living trust. It’s the most common type of planned gift and often the simplest for a donor to arrange. When a supporter decides to leave a bequest, they are making a plan during their lifetime for a gift that your nonprofit will receive after they’re gone. This can be a specific dollar amount, a percentage of their estate, or even a piece of property. Because bequests are so straightforward, they are the foundation of many successful legacy giving programs and a great place to start.

Charitable gift annuities

A charitable gift annuity is a bit more involved, but it offers a unique benefit to the donor. Here’s how it works: a supporter makes a sizable donation to your nonprofit, and in return, you agree to pay them a fixed income for the rest of their life. After they pass away, your organization keeps the remaining balance of the gift. This can be an attractive option for older supporters who want to contribute to your mission while also securing a steady income stream for themselves. These are formal agreements, so you should always encourage donors to speak with a financial advisor.

Beneficiary designations

This is one of the easiest legacy gifts a supporter can make. A donor can name your nonprofit as a beneficiary on accounts like a life insurance policy, a retirement plan (such as an IRA or 401(k)), or even a bank account. Often, making this change is as simple as filling out a form with their plan administrator, and it doesn’t require them to update their will. This is a powerful, low-friction way for someone to leave a significant gift. By promoting this option, you can open the door for supporters who want to give but may not have other assets to pledge.

Donor-advised funds

Donor-advised funds (DAFs) are like charitable investment accounts, and they are becoming an increasingly popular way for people to manage their giving. A supporter can also use their DAF to leave a legacy gift. They can do this by naming your nonprofit as the successor or beneficiary of their account. This means that after their lifetime, the remaining funds in their DAF will be transferred directly to your organization. For donors who already use a DAF, this is a simple and efficient way to plan a gift and continue their support for the causes they love.

Charitable remainder trusts

A charitable remainder trust (CRT) is another option that provides income back to the donor. It’s similar to a gift annuity but structured as a trust. A donor transfers assets into the trust, which then pays an income to them or their chosen beneficiaries for a set number of years or for life. When the trust term ends, the remaining assets are distributed to your nonprofit. CRTs are sophisticated financial tools, so it’s essential to build trust with your donors and encourage them to seek professional legal and financial advice before setting one up.

Why Legacy Giving Is a Win-Win

A strong legacy giving program is one of the most powerful ways to build a sustainable future for your organization. But it’s not just about securing funds for tomorrow. It’s a deeply meaningful opportunity for your supporters to make their values last a lifetime and beyond. When you frame it this way, legacy giving becomes less of a transaction and more of a partnership, creating a true win-win for everyone involved. It all starts with building authentic relationships, often through channels like social direct messaging, where you can have personal conversations at scale.

Secure your nonprofit’s financial future

Legacy giving, also known as planned giving, creates a predictable and powerful revenue stream that can stabilize your nonprofit for years to come. These are future gifts that supporters arrange to give through their will, a retirement account, or a life insurance policy. According to the National Council of Nonprofits, there is a huge amount of potential funding available through planned gifts that most organizations aren't tapping into. A single legacy gift can be transformative, helping you establish or grow an endowment that provides reliable funding every single year. This long-term financial security allows you to move beyond short-term fundraising cycles and focus on expanding your mission’s impact.

The benefits for your donors

For your supporters, legacy giving is a profound way to make a lasting statement about what matters most to them. It’s an opportunity to ensure the causes and community they believe in will continue to receive support long after they are gone. This act of giving provides a sense of purpose and fulfillment, allowing a donor to cement their personal values into a tangible legacy. By inviting your supporters to consider a planned gift, you are offering them a special role in your organization's future. You’re giving them a chance to make their generosity a permanent part of your story and continue helping the community they care about.

Understanding the tax advantages

While the emotional connection is key, there are also practical financial benefits for your donors. Planned gifts can offer significant tax advantages, including breaks on estate and income taxes. It’s a common misconception that only the very wealthy can leave a legacy gift. The truth is, you don’t need a massive estate to make a difference. Many legacy gifts are small percentages of an estate, often just 1% to 5%. This can still provide meaningful support for your cause without taking away from what a donor wants to leave for their family. Highlighting this fact makes the conversation more approachable and opens the door to a wider pool of potential legacy donors.

How to Start a Legacy Giving Program in 8 Steps

Launching a legacy giving program might sound like a massive undertaking, but it’s more about thoughtful planning than a huge budget. At its core, a legacy program is about deepening relationships with your most dedicated supporters. It’s a long-term strategy that honors their commitment and secures your nonprofit’s future. By following these eight steps, you can build a program that feels authentic to your mission and manageable for your team.

1. See if your nonprofit is ready

First, let’s be clear: being "ready" for legacy giving isn’t about having a team of lawyers on standby. It’s about having strong, established relationships with your donors. A successful program is built on trust and connection, not complex legal paperwork. Think about your most loyal supporters. Do you have a group of people who have consistently stood by your mission? If so, you have the foundation you need. This is the perfect opportunity to build 1:1 relationships and show these supporters how they can make a lasting impact. Legacy giving is the ultimate expression of a donor’s belief in your work, and it often inspires them to give more generously today.

2. Decide which gifts to accept

You don’t need to become an expert in every type of planned gift overnight. The best approach is to start simple. The most common and straightforward legacy gift is a bequest, which is a gift made through a will or trust. It’s easy for donors to understand and simple for nonprofits to manage. By focusing on bequests first, you can get your program off the ground without getting overwhelmed. As your program matures and your team gains confidence, you can explore other options like beneficiary designations on retirement accounts or life insurance policies. The key is to start with a manageable scope and grow from there.

3. Create your gift acceptance policy

A gift acceptance policy sounds formal, but it’s really just a set of simple guidelines for your team. This document outlines which types of legacy gifts your organization is prepared to accept and the procedures for handling them. It doesn’t have to be a 50-page legal treatise; a one or two-page document is often enough to start. This policy protects your nonprofit by ensuring you don’t accept gifts with complicated strings attached or assets that are difficult to manage. It also gives your staff the clarity and confidence they need when talking to donors. Think of it as a helpful playbook for your fundraising team.

4. Get your team on board

A legacy giving program can’t succeed as a solo project. You need buy-in from your entire organization, especially your board of directors. Your board members are your most powerful advocates, and their enthusiasm is contagious. Start by educating them on how legacy giving provides long-term financial stability for the mission they care so much about. The best way to get them on board is to ask them to lead by example and consider making their own planned gifts. When your leadership is personally invested, it sends a powerful message to staff, volunteers, and your entire donor community that legacy giving is a priority.

5. Find your potential legacy donors

Your best legacy donor prospects are likely already in your database. These are your most loyal supporters, the ones who have given consistently year after year. A good place to start is by identifying donors who have made gifts for eight or more years. These individuals have demonstrated a deep, long-term commitment to your cause. They’re not just giving; they believe in your vision for the future. These loyal supporters are also often your most engaged followers on social media. You can use your social channels to nurture these relationships and gently introduce the idea of legacy giving through personal, direct messages.

6. Develop your marketing materials

You don’t need a glossy, expensive marketing campaign to promote your legacy program. Start small and integrate legacy giving messages into the communications you already produce. Create a simple one-page brochure that explains what a bequest is and how it helps your mission. Add a sentence to your email signature, like "Want to make a lasting impact? Consider leaving a gift in your will." You can also include a short article in your next newsletter. The goal is to plant a seed and make your supporters aware that this is an option. It’s a soft, consistent approach that keeps legacy giving top of mind without being pushy.

7. Build a dedicated landing page

In a digital world, having a dedicated space on your website for legacy giving is essential. This page acts as a central hub where interested supporters can learn more on their own time, without any pressure. Your landing page should clearly explain how to leave a gift, the impact it will have, and who to contact with questions. Including a few powerful impact stories from other donors can be incredibly inspiring. You can also use this page to answer frequently asked questions and introduce your legacy society if you have one. Make it easy to find, easy to understand, and focused on the donor’s desire to make a difference.

8. Thank and celebrate your legacy donors

When a donor informs you that they’ve included your organization in their will, it’s a huge moment. They are placing their trust in you to carry their values into the future. It’s critical to acknowledge this profound commitment immediately and personally. A simple, heartfelt thank-you note goes a long way. This isn’t just about good manners; it’s about stewarding the relationship. By celebrating these donors, you make them feel seen and appreciated, which keeps them connected to your mission. This personal touch reinforces their decision and can even inspire others to follow their lead.

What Inspires a Legacy Donor to Give?

At its heart, legacy giving is about so much more than money. It’s a deeply personal decision that allows a supporter to make a lasting impact on a cause they’ve championed throughout their life. For many donors, the motivation is the desire for their support to continue long after they are gone, creating a powerful statement about their values and passions. Think of it as a way for them to ensure the work they care about doesn’t just stop; it grows and thrives for future generations.

This type of giving is a profound act of trust and belief in your mission. When a donor includes your nonprofit in their estate plans, they are saying they believe in your organization's future and its ability to continue making a difference. Understanding this core inspiration is key. Your conversations and marketing shouldn't just focus on the financial transaction but on the incredible opportunity for a supporter to create a meaningful legacy. By framing it this way, you shift the focus from a complex financial process to a beautiful, enduring act of generosity.

Who is your ideal legacy donor?

Let’s clear up a common myth: legacy donors are not just the ultra-wealthy. While large estates can certainly result in transformative gifts, your most promising legacy prospects are often hiding in plain sight. Your ideal legacy donors are typically your most loyal supporters. These are the people who have demonstrated their commitment by giving consistently over many years, often for eight or more years.

They are already invested in your success. It’s also important to remember that many legacy gifts are small percentages of an estate, like 1% to 5%. A small portion can still provide significant, sustainable support for your nonprofit without taking away from what a donor wants to leave for their family. This makes legacy giving an accessible option for a much wider group of supporters than you might think.

Build the relationship before you ask

Planned giving is fundamentally a relationship-building activity, not a paperwork-filing one. The legal documents are the final step, but the journey to get there is paved with genuine connection and trust. Starting these conversations early is crucial. Don’t wait until a donor is older or you assume they are thinking about estate planning. The strongest planned giving programs are built on years of consistent communication and stewardship.

Focusing on the relationship first not only helps secure future gifts but can also lead to larger contributions today. When a donor feels seen, heard, and valued, they become more invested in your mission. Nurturing these connections through personalized outreach, like one-to-one messages and updates, shows them you care about them as a person, not just as a potential gift.

Address legal and financial questions early

Many nonprofits hesitate to start a legacy program because they worry they don’t have the legal or financial expertise on staff. Here’s the good news: you don’t need to be an attorney or a financial planner. Your role is to be a helpful facilitator, not an expert advisor. When you launch your program, it’s important to have a plan for handling these questions.

Your primary job is to inspire the gift and build the relationship. For the technical parts, you can simply connect donors with their own legal and financial advisors. You can provide general information and sample language, but always encourage supporters to seek professional counsel to ensure their gift is structured correctly and meets their personal goals. This approach allows you to focus on what you do best: sharing your mission.

How to Market Your Legacy Program

Once you have the basics of your legacy giving program in place, it’s time to share it with your supporters. Marketing your program isn’t about a hard sell or creating false urgency; it’s about making your community aware of a powerful way they can support your mission for years to come. Think of it as planting seeds. Your goal is to gently and consistently communicate the opportunity, building awareness and trust over time. This approach respects the thoughtful and personal nature of a planned gift.

The key is to integrate your message across different channels, meeting your donors where they are and making legacy giving feel like a natural and accessible option for anyone who cares deeply about your cause. It's about storytelling, education, and community building. You're not just asking for a future donation; you're inviting your most loyal supporters into a deeper partnership, one that solidifies their place in your organization's history. A thoughtful marketing strategy demystifies the process and shows donors how they can create a lasting impact, ensuring your nonprofit has a sustainable future. By following these steps, you can build a marketing plan that inspires generosity and secures your mission for generations.

Start a legacy society to build community

Creating a legacy society is a wonderful way to recognize and celebrate donors who have pledged a future gift. Think of it as an exclusive club for your most committed supporters. Give the society a special name, maybe one that reflects your mission or history, and create a simple logo. This simple act of branding makes membership feel special.

A legacy society builds a community around shared values and long-term vision. It provides social proof that encourages others to consider making their own planned gift. You can honor members at special events, list their names in your annual report (with permission, of course), and provide them with exclusive updates. This recognition is a form of ongoing stewardship that keeps donors connected to your work and affirms their decision to invest in your future.

Lead with powerful impact stories

Facts and figures can explain what you do, but stories are what truly connect with people’s hearts. When marketing your legacy program, lead with personal and powerful stories of impact. Share testimonials from donors who have already included your organization in their estate plans. Focus on their "why"—the personal reasons and deep-seated beliefs that inspired them to make this ultimate gift.

These narratives are incredibly effective because they show potential donors that people just like them are making these commitments. You can also tell stories about the future impact these gifts will have, painting a vivid picture of the world your donors are helping to create. You can even offer to help donors write and share their stories, making them a central part of your nonprofit’s ongoing legacy.

Host educational events and webinars

Many potential legacy donors have questions about the process, from estate planning to tax implications. You can become a trusted resource by hosting educational events or webinars. These events shouldn't feel like a sales pitch. Instead, focus on providing genuine value to your supporters. Partner with local attorneys or financial advisors to speak on topics like creating a will or understanding different gift types.

By offering free, expert advice, you build trust and position your organization as a helpful guide. During these events, you can gently weave in information about your legacy program and share a few donor stories to connect the practical information back to your mission. This approach helps demystify planned giving and empowers your supporters to take the next step when they’re ready.

Use social media and DMs to connect

Legacy giving might feel traditional, but your marketing strategy can be completely modern. Your social media channels are perfect for sharing information about your legacy program. You can post donor testimonials, explain the impact of planned gifts, and answer frequently asked questions in a public forum. This helps normalize the idea of legacy giving for your entire audience.

Even better, you can use social media to start personal conversations. When someone engages with a post about legacy giving, it’s an open door to connect with them through direct messaging. A simple, friendly DM can answer a private question, provide a link to more information, or begin the relationship-building process. It’s a low-pressure way to identify and nurture potential legacy donors within the community you’ve already built online.

Plan a multi-channel outreach campaign

To successfully market your legacy program, you need to reach your supporters through various channels. Don’t just send one email and hope for the best. Instead, weave legacy giving into the fabric of your existing communications. Add a simple line about planned giving to your email signature. Include a short article in your quarterly newsletter. Create a simple, elegant brochure that you can share with major donors.

A dedicated landing page on your website is also essential, serving as a central hub for all information. The goal is to make legacy giving a visible, consistent, and normal part of supporting your organization. By planning a multi-channel campaign, you ensure your message reaches the right people at the right time, making it easy for them to say "yes" to leaving a lasting impact.

Overcoming Common Legacy Giving Hurdles

Starting a legacy giving program can feel like a huge undertaking, especially when you’re already juggling so many priorities. It’s easy to get stuck on the potential challenges: what if we don’t have the budget, our team isn’t on board, or we don’t know how to talk to donors about it?

These are completely valid concerns, but they don’t have to be roadblocks. With a thoughtful approach, you can work through these common hurdles and build a program that secures your nonprofit’s future. Let’s break down how to handle these challenges one by one.

Working with a limited budget or staff

You don’t need a massive budget or a dedicated planned giving officer to get started. Many nonprofits launch successful programs with limited resources by starting small and focusing on the essentials. A basic program can be established with a modest investment in simple marketing materials and staff time. The key is to focus on low-cost, high-impact activities.

You can begin by adding a legacy giving option to your website and including a mention in your email newsletters. As your program grows, you can reinvest in more resources. The initial effort is an investment that builds a sustainable source of future income, making it one of the most efficient forms of fundraising you can do.

Shifting your internal culture

For a legacy program to truly succeed, it needs to be part of your organization's DNA. This means shifting the mindset from short-term fundraising goals to long-term relationship building. Planned giving is about using direct messaging for nonprofits to connect with your most loyal supporters, not just processing legal paperwork. To make this shift, start with your leadership.

Get your board members involved by educating them on the long-term impact and encouraging them to make their own planned gifts first. When your board leads by example, it sends a powerful message. You can also train your entire team, not just fundraisers, to recognize and nurture conversations about legacy giving. This creates a culture where everyone understands their role in securing your organization's future.

Answering donor questions and concerns

Many potential donors have misconceptions about legacy giving. They might think it’s only for the wealthy or that the process is too complicated. Your job is to make it feel accessible and straightforward. You can do this by proactively addressing their questions and showing them how simple it can be to leave a lasting impact.

Create a simple FAQ page on your website or a one-page handout that busts common myths. Explain that anyone can make a legacy gift and that it doesn't have to be a complex process. You can also host educational webinars to walk supporters through their options, from leaving a gift in their will to naming your organization as a beneficiary of a retirement account. By providing clear, helpful information, you empower donors to make a choice that feels right for them.

Weaving Legacy Giving Into Your Fundraising

Legacy giving shouldn't be a separate, walled-off part of your fundraising strategy. Instead of treating it like a special project, think of it as the natural extension of the relationships you’re already building with your most dedicated supporters. When you weave legacy giving conversations into your existing fundraising efforts, you create a more holistic and sustainable program. It’s about integrating the idea of a final, powerful gift into the entire donor journey, from their first social media interaction to their annual fund contribution. This approach makes the concept feel more accessible to donors and more manageable for your team.

Connect planned gifts with your annual fund

Think of your annual fund as the foundation and planned giving as the long-term vision. The two work together beautifully. Planned giving is about building strong relationships, not just handling legal paperwork. These deeper connections often lead to more significant gifts today while also securing future support. You can start by simply adding a checkbox to your annual fund reply forms that says, "I'm interested in learning more about including [Your Nonprofit's Name] in my will." This small step opens the door for a conversation without pressure, allowing you to identify potential legacy donors among your most consistent givers.

Use social fundraising to build your pipeline

Your social media channels are powerful tools for more than just immediate donations; they're perfect for building your legacy giving pipeline. You can use platforms like Facebook to host educational events that provide real value to your followers. Consider partnering with a local financial advisor or attorney to host a webinar on estate planning basics. By framing these events around helpful information rather than a direct ask, you position your nonprofit as a trusted resource. This approach helps you build a community and identify supporters who are thinking about their long-term impact, giving you a natural way to introduce legacy giving.

Turn social followers into legacy donors

So, who are your best prospects for legacy gifts? Your most loyal donors. These are often the people who have given consistently over many years. The challenge is identifying and connecting with them, especially on social media where they might just be a name on your follower list. This is where building genuine, one-to-one relationships becomes critical. By using direct messaging to thank supporters and share impact stories, you can turn anonymous followers into engaged partners. These conversations help you discover who your most passionate advocates are, creating the perfect opportunity to introduce them to the idea of leaving a lasting legacy.

Related Articles

• 12 Big Money Fundraising Ideas for Nonprofits
• The 2026 Tax Laws Just Opened the Door to 90% of Americans as New Donors
• Effective Donor Retention Tips for Growing Organizations
• 5 Reasons Why Nonprofits Are Losing Donors

Frequently Asked Questions

We're a small nonprofit with a tiny budget. Is legacy giving realistic for us? Absolutely. A legacy program is less about a big budget and more about strong relationships. You don't need a fancy campaign to get started. Begin by simply deciding to accept bequests, which are gifts left in a will. You can promote this by adding a sentence to your email signature and creating a simple page on your website. The most important part, building trust with your loyal supporters, is something you're likely already doing.

Do I need to be a legal or financial expert to talk to donors about this? Not at all, and you shouldn't try to be. Your role is to be the passionate expert on your mission, not a financial advisor. Your job is to inspire donors by showing them the incredible, lasting impact their gift could have. When it comes to the technical details, you can simply and confidently guide them to speak with their own attorney or financial planner to work out the specifics.

How do I bring up legacy giving without making donors feel uncomfortable? This is a great question, and it comes down to framing. Instead of talking about money or estate plans, talk about values and vision. Frame the conversation around a donor's desire to make a lasting impact on a cause they love. You can ask, "Have you ever thought about how you'd like your support for our mission to continue in the future?" This shifts the focus from an end-of-life transaction to a beautiful, forward-looking act of generosity.

What's the single most important first step to get a program started? The most important first step is getting your board of directors on board. Their support is crucial because they set the tone for the entire organization. Educate them on how legacy gifts provide long-term stability, and then ask them to lead by example and consider making their own planned gifts. Once your leadership is invested, every other step, from creating a policy to marketing the program, becomes much easier.

How do I find potential legacy donors if I don't have a fancy wealth screening tool? You don't need one. Your best prospects are your most loyal supporters, not necessarily your wealthiest. Look through your database for people who have given consistently for five or more years, even if the amounts are small. These are the people who have proven they believe in your mission for the long haul. They are your true believers, and they are the perfect people to invite into a conversation about creating a lasting legacy.